DEC. 24. 2009 -- Like layers of an onion being cut by a knife, the opinions of the people of South Carolina are coming into crisper view. Or is it a “crankier” view?
Nearly two of every five of the 770 registered South Carolina voters contacted in a Dec. 15 InsiderAdvantage/Statehouse Report poll said they felt the state was headed in the “wrong direction.”
Not surprisingly, more Democratic respondents, the state’s opposition party, were critical than their counterparts in the Republican Party. Nearly 52 percent of Democrats, compared to 34 percent of Republicans, felt the state was headed in the wrong direction.
Those aged 30 to 44, who still have higher-earning years ahead of them, were the most worried. Nearly 46 percent said they thought the state was headed in wrong direction, regardless of party affiliation.
Ashley Woodiwiss, a political science professor at Erskine College, said considering the state‘s current political and economic context, the poll had some “remarkable” findings, particularly “in the face of the political crisis precipitated by our governor's national scandal and with some of the worst economic conditions in this state since the Great Depression.”
He said for only 39 percent of those polled to say the state was headed in the wrong direction meant 60 percent seemed at least content.
“A full 60 percent either have no opinion -- 29 percent -- or, more staggeringly, believe South Carolina is actually heading in the right direction -- 32 percent . This is truly remarkable indeed.”
Reading between the poll’s lines, Woodiwiss said public opinion had changed little on major issues -- jobs, education and more. He said that wouldn‘t have concerned him had 2009 been a “normal“ year.
“And yet all the objective evidence around us -- unemployment, education, even more budget cuts, et cetera -- indicates that these are not normal times,” said Woodiwiss. “Rather, we may well be in a state of political and economic crisis. But apparently for most South Carolinians, despite this evidence, all seems, well, good enough.”
With just over half of self-described Democrats responding that the state is going in the wrong direction, “with even the most generous interpretive allowance given, what this question captures is that for most of our fellow citizens, there is not a great deal of serious disaffection with the state of our state,” he said.
Jeri Cabot, a political scientist at the College of Charleston, said she was amazed that nearly 30 percent of those polled had “no opinion” for the direction of the state.
Cabot said that this portion of the poll might show that South Carolinians are confused about who should be blamed for the state’s current situation, and that many might have settled on the state’s economic woes being the federal government’s fault.
A Haley of a surprise
The biggest winner of the poll seemed to be gubernatorial candidate state Rep. Nikki Haley (R-Lexington) -- if coming in third among GOP candidates can be considered a “win.”
Yes, Haley only received the nod from 13 percent of registered voters who said they would cast ballots in the GOP primary next year. But after the tumultuous fall from grace of Gov. Mark Sanford, with whom she had sided with on House battles and in the tone of her early campaign, 10 points short of the overall lead may be considered impressive. Furthermore, she polled ahead of Congressman Gresham Barrett. His fourth-place showing is sure to shock some in the business community who have seen him as the best GOP candidate in the race.
That state Attorney General Henry McMaster was tied for the overall lead at 22 percent may not surprise some. What was surprising was that it took independents and the 65-plus age group of voters to bring him into an overall tie with Lt. Gov. Andre Bauer, who, ironically, runs the state’s Office on Aging and has been courting the silver-haired crowd heavily.
Among those polled who identified themselves as Republicans, Bauer beat McMaster 24-21 percent. Bauer also cleaned up with the 18-29 year olds (53 percent), while Barrett’s best showing was tied for second in the 45-64 age group, with 12.5 percent.
Rex, Drake on Democratic side
Voters for the Democratic primary seemed to be suffering from a bout of indecision or plain lack of information. When asked which candidate they would vote for if the Democratic primary were held today, more said they had “no opinion” -- 44 percent -- than those that said they would vote for the top four party candidates.
And, considering the poll had a 3.4-percent margin of error, more Democrats seem to be on the fence than have picked a side.
State Superintendent of Education Jim Rex, perhaps buoyed by statewide name recognition, led the pack with 21 percent overall, and 16.6 percent within self-identified Democrats polled. In second place was attorney/lobbyist Dwight Drake who was tied with Rex among Dems at 16.6 percent, and second overall with 15 percent. Coming in third was state Sen. Vincent Sheheen, D-Kershaw, with 8 percent.
Cabot expressed surprise that more female voters hadn’t abandoned the GOP for the Democratic slate considering Gov. Mark Sanford’s much-reported philandering.
Crystal ball: Conventional wisdom is that early polling in gubernatorial races is heavily influenced by name recognition -- Bauer, McMaster and Rex all hold statewide offices -- and that the quality of candidate and money are more influential later in the race. Regardless, whoever wins the governor’s race will have a significant chunk of the South Carolinians thinking that the state is headed in the wrong direction.