JAN. 10, 2014 -- South Carolina legislators said this week they wanted to see more details in a K-12 education plan that Republican Gov. Nikki Haley says is her number one priority now. She has spent the past year gathering input for the proposal, part of which includes nearly $100 million for helping students in poverty-stricken areas. The effort makes Haley the first governor to be serious about addressing the problem of growing disparity between poor schools and wealthier districts since a landmark school equity lawsuit was filed on behalf of several rural school districts 20 years ago, says Bud Ferillo, who produced and directed the 2005 award-winning documentary “Corridor of Shame: The Neglect of South Carolina's Rural Schools.” (The State Supreme Court has yet to make a decision in that case — yes, two decades later.)
In the early 2000s, Democratic Gov. Jim Hodges brought a state lottery to South Carolina where $687 million in proceeds have gone to K-12 education since 2002. Under the administration of Republican Gov. Mark Sanford, the school choice movement —public support for private schools — was a priority.
Haley's plan includes:
- Nearly $100 million for poverty-stricken students.
- Nearly $30 million to beef up broadband capabilities.
- About $30 million to hire teaching coaches.
Lawmakers and education advocates are hoping more details come out as they debate the issue.
“We're going to have to make sure monies are there and not start programs where money isn't there,” said Spartanburg Republican Rep. Rita Allison, who is on the House Ways and Means Committee and was an education advisor to Sanford.
Haley has said no new taxes would be needed to pay for her education plan.
Now is the time for education ... and politics
The Palmetto State's financial landscape has been improving in recent years, and its budget outlook is about where it was just prior to the Great Recession, according to State Budget Director Les Boles. The money for Haley's proposal will come from up to $400 million in new tax revenue that budget forecasters expect the state to reap.
Education reform is likely to play out in two arenas this year: under the copper dome of the Statehouse in Columbia, and in a hotly contested rematch campaign for governor between Haley and likely Democratic nominee Vincent Sheheen.
The Camden senator and lawyer has made his own education plan a priority, which focuses on government-funded statewide 4-year-old kindergarten. Legislative Democrats support his plan to expand a program that currently only includes at-risk children in 36 of the state's 46 counties. Last year, Sheheen was the driving force behind adding $26 million for the program for at-risk children.
Democrats so far have played a kind of rhetorical jujitsu with Haley on her education package.
“I’m glad the governor is now making funding for rural public schools a priority. Senate Democrats have long advocated for additional funding for poor, rural school districts,” said Senate Minority Leader Nikki Setzler of Lexington. “This past year, we led the effort to expand state funded 4-old-kindergarten for at-risk children so that 4K is now available to at-risk children in more than 50 school districts, many in rural areas. Continued expansion of state-funded 4 year-old-kindergarten needs to be a part of any education plan going forward.” And Orangeburg Democratic Sen. Brad Hutto said he “belatedly” welcomed Haley to the issue.
They have some context and recent history on their side.
The State newspaper reported last summer that education spending made up a quarter of Haley's vetoes since she took office in 2010. Her veto strikes have added up to more than $200 million in public education spending. As a lawmaker when it came to education, Haley was a vocal champion of school choice proposals that would have diverted public money to private schools. That's opened the door for the state Democratic Party to frame the governor's new public education plan as a “Hail Mary initiative launched in the midst of her reelection campaign.”
But public education advocates outside the Legislature have given initial praise to Haley's focus on low-income students. And absent from her plan are the school-choice measures to give tax breaks for families with children in private schools, something that has become a divisive issue at the Statehouse in the past decade.
Welcome, refreshing
“Any emphasis on the plight of the rural districts is welcome, regardless of who proposes them,” Ferillo said.
Debbie Elmore, a spokesman for the South Carolina School Boards Association, called Haley's stance on wanting to address public school funding refreshing.
“Everything she said was very positive … and that's been a void for a long time,” Elmore said, adding that an advocate in the executive office focusing on public education has been lacking for years. “So that was very nice.”
But Elmore worried the plan did not go far enough to address fundamental flaws in the state's tax structure that affect the way money flows to public schools.
In 2006, for instance, lawmakers passed Act 388, which removed residential property taxes from school funding essentially to give tax relief for coastal property homeowners whose taxes had gone up. At the same time, it raised the sales taxes to 6 cents per dollar in hopes that it would make up the difference. But an economic downturn led to dropping sales tax collections and hurt poor counties. There's not been the will at the Statehouse to revisit Act 388, despite grumblings from many corners.
Elmore said she hoped that becomes part of the conversation moving forward.
Republican and Democratic lawmakers agree that a child living in a poor or wealthy part of South Carolina shouldn't affect what kind of education the child receives at a public school based on funding. But some said they wanted concrete details before making a commitment to taking up Haley's plan.
House Speaker Bobby Harrell, R-Charleston, didn't fully embrace Haley's education agenda when asked about it this week by reporters. He said he saw education as a top priority in 2014 in the sense that education was a subset of the economy.
Corey Hutchins is a reporter with the Charleston City Paper and contributor to Statehouse Report.
RECENT NEWS STORIES